With so many Caribbean islands to choose from it can be hard to decide which one is the right fit for your vacation. From upscale islands like St. Barths and Turks & Caicos to romantic islands like St. Lucia and dozens more in between they all offer a different experience and culture. Aruba and Curaçao are both Dutch islands as well as Bonaire — commonly referred to as the “ABC” islands. This string of islands are closer to the Venezuelan coast and easy to get to from east coast with many direct flights from Miami, Charlotte and New York.

Even though they are all Dutch islands, they cater to totally different types of travelers. Aruba is better suited for families and travelers who need the comforts of home. In many ways Aruba reminds me of touristy areas in Mexico where you’ll see souvenir stands and American chain restaurants. If your main goal is to relax on the beach, go for an occasional swim and hit the slot machines Aruba is a cost-effective and easy destination.

For travelers who’ve visited other Caribbean islands and want more culture and boutique hotels, Curaçao is the perfect choice. The capital city, Willemstad is very colorful and European feeling, but it’s also a major cruise stop so the town is flooded with tourists when ships come in to port. Personally, I love Curaçao and would return again just to enjoy the beautiful Baoase Resort.

What to know before you go

You’ll see plenty of Americans on both islands, however Curaçao has a much heavier Dutch influence so expect to see more European travelers.
People typically speak three languages on the islands - Dutch (the official language), Papiamento (most common), and English.
The U.S. dollar is accepted on both islands and almost all menus, hotels, activities, etc. are priced in $.
Unlike many of the other islands, Aruba, Curaçao, and Bonaire are located outside of the hurricane belt. The weather remains nearly perfect year-round. Expect higher temps and humidity in the summer of course, but no closures in August - October, maybe some quick afternoon showers.
Oranjestad and Willemstad are both port cities for major cruise lines, try to time your outings to miss the crowds.

Aruba Hotels

Ritz Carlton Aruba - The only true 5-star hotel on the island (until the St. Regis opens!). It’s a huge property with separate pools for kids and adults, beach cabanas, multiple onsite restaurants and club level access available for guests.
Hyatt Regency Aruba - Love this hotel for kids and families, they have a lazy river and an adults-only pool. The rooms are simple, but almost all have an ocean view.
Bucuti & Tara Beach Resort - Great choice for couples and honeymooners, it’s adults-only, LGBTQ friendly with a big focus on sustainability . One of the few family-owned hotels on the island and you’ll surely see them on property.

Curaçao Hotels

Baoase Resort - One of my favorite hotels in all of Caribbean. It’s family-owned and they are very hands-on with the everything regarding the hotel. The service is incredible and feels more like you’re staying at your friend’s very nice beach house. Ounwinverall a relaxing vibe and great place to unwind.

Sandals Royal Curaçao - This is one of the newer properties in their portfolio and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the rooms and many dining outlets. The hotel was perfectly maintained and this is a great choice for couples who want more activities and nightlife.

Zoëtry Curaçao Resort & Spa - A little more trendy and affordable. They share amenities with Dreams.